Ireland or Scotland – Which Destination Should You Choose?
Are you ready for a new adventure? Making the leap from domestic to international travel can be overwhelming, especially when it comes to deciding where you want to go. If you’re embarking on your first trip out of the country, you might be looking for a destination with enriching new experiences while still offering the comfort of friendly, welcoming locals who speak English. You’ll find just that with a trip to the United Kingdom (UK) and Ireland. While venturing over the Atlantic might seem intimidating, it’s not as far as you may think – in fact, the flight time is about the same as going to Hawaii!
For guests interested in these spectacular destinations, one question we’re often asked is which trip to choose. As travel experts of 50 years, we’re here to break down the main differences among these phenomenal trips so you can decide which inspires your wanderlust. Rest assured, every trip includes the Holiday Advantage benefits, such as round-trip airfare, exceptional accommodations, professional Tour Directors, must-see attractions, local dining, and more.
So, without further ado, let’s dive in!
Ireland vs. Northern Ireland
Wait, isn’t it all one country? This is a common misconception among first-time visitors and those who are not from that region. While it is in fact one island, it is two separate countries - Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland. To start, the Republic of Ireland is a sovereign state and is part of the European Union (EU). Northern Ireland, however, is part of the UK, which has not been part of the EU since 2020. Therefore, you will also see differences in governance. The Republic of Ireland is governed by their President, currently Michael Higgins, while Northern Ireland is ruled by the British Monarch, King Charles III. However, when it comes to day-to-day governing, both countries are overseen by their respective Prime Ministers, or Taoiseach in Ireland.
If you visit both countries, you’ll need two different currencies. Ireland uses the Euro, while Northern Ireland and the rest of the UK uses the Pound Sterling. However, the easiest form of money to bring when visiting is Visa or Mastercard, as both are widely accepted throughout the entire island.
The primary differences – separation, currencies, and governance – are what mainly distinguish the two countries. Generally, it can be deduced that Northern Ireland follows what the rest of the UK does while Ireland, as its own free state, has more individual standards unique to their country. There are additional, more in-depth details and a ton of history that goes into why this is how it is, which we can uncover together while visiting them!
With that cleared up, let’s look into the role Scotland plays in the relationship between Ireland and Northern Ireland.
Ireland & Northern Ireland vs. Scotland
Ireland, Northern Ireland, and Scotland seem very similar geographically and, in someways, culturally, but there are some main differences that set the countries apart.
Generally speaking, Scotland has more of a dramatic and diverse landscape than Ireland and Northern Ireland, but comparatively has less of a unique history as Ireland. Since Scotland is part of the UK, you will still see British influences present today as well as a melting pot of ancestry – Gaelic Celtic, Brythonic Celtic, Anglo-Saxon, and Norse. Speaking to the island of Ireland as a whole, you’ll find most Irish are Gaelic Celtic. There are so many Gaelic Celtic people that you can find areas in Ireland – called Gaeltacht regions – where the Irish language was, until recently, the primary spoken language.
Majestic mountains, rugged coastlines, and gorgeous waterways make up Scotland’s natural scenery and are a significant attraction for the country. While Ireland and Northern Ireland also have an abundance of scenic beauty, their historically significant sites and lively nightlife are what draw in tourists from around the world. When it comes to climates, both the island of Ireland and Scotland are known for heavy cloud coverage and milder climates in comparison to the rest of Continental Europe. Scotland can have more extreme weather, with warmer temps and a touch more humidity than Ireland and Northern Ireland.
Now that we’ve covered the history and distinct differences throughout these three incredible destinations, is there one that you find most intriguing? Don’t make your decision quite yet; it’s time to get a glimpse into what you will experience on each of our tours!
Top 3 Attractions: Enchanting Ireland
Do you want to enjoy rich history, natural beauty, and vibrant culture? Look no further than Ireland, a popular destination for first-time international travelers for good reason. There’s no shortage of captivating adventures for everyone to enjoy on the Emerald Isle – from a guided tour of the capital city, Dublin, to a merry feast in medieval Bunratty.
Admire the stunning Victorian architecture of the neo-Gothic Church of Kylemore Abbey, situated in the heart of the gorgeous and remote Connemara Countryside. Enjoy a scenic walk through the grounds’ colorful gardens and take in the intricate craftsmanship of the Abbey’s interior. Built in the late 1800s, the castle has been owned and inhabited by the Benedictine Community of Nuns since World War I. Experience generations of history, tradition, and nature’s splendor at this magnificent estate.
Immerse yourself in a unique cultural experience at Kate Kearney’s Cottage. This award-winning restaurant and bar has been family-owned for 150 years and is nestled in Killarney’s charming countryside, near the entrance to the famous Gap of Dunloe. The building is adorned with red doors that lead inside to a quaint gift shop and an interior brimming with rustic charm. Enjoy the ambiance of a traditional Irish night with folk music by local musicians and costumed dancing.
Visit Blarney Castle to revel in 600 years of fascinating history. Legend has it that kissing the Blarney Stone will give one the gift of gab, or the ability to speak with eloquence and persuasiveness. This fabled stone is a large part of what attracts tourists, but there’s plenty more to do here. Lush gardens dot the land surrounding the castle, growing everything from poisonous herbs to carnivorous plants. Admire a wide variety of rare tree species, some of which are nearly 300 years old.
Top 3 Attractions: Scotland & Northern Ireland
Scotland is a charming country, and pairing it with the beauty of Northern Ireland makes this another spectacular trip. In fact, we even venture into the Republic of Ireland to visit Dublin, so you experience three countries! It’s intriguing to witness the difference between cultures and accents – though all are English speaking. From ancient castles to Loch Lomond, we’ve filled this itinerary with extraordinary attractions and activities.
Discover the magic of Inveraray Castle, the long-time seat of Clan Campbell. This sprawling fortress on the 50,000-acre Argyll Estate has sat overlooking Loch Fyne since the 1400s, although a fire in 1877 resulted in some rebuilding and the eye-catching conical roofs of the castle corners. It remains a private residence today for the 13th Duke of Argyll, but we tour many luxurious areas, such as the Armoury Hall, grand State Dining Room, and the North West Hall, where the Duke’s Coronation robes can be seen.
Walk through the life of royalty in Edinburgh, where we receive a guided tour of The Royal Yacht Britannia, also referred to as the “Floating Palace.” The Britannia has sailed over one million miles around the world and the Royal Family, including the late Queen Elizabeth II, has used it as a vacation home for over 40 years! It was staffed with 240 Royal Yachtsmen and has been part of Royal honeymoons, family holidays, official receptions, and much more.
Travel to Northern Ireland’s majestic coast to discover the geological wonder known as Giant’s Causeway. Recognized as a UNESCO World Heritage Site, it is one of the country’s most popular tourist attractions due to its fascinating natural beauty. Step out onto ancient basalt columns, formed around 50 million years ago during volcanic activity in the area, to take in the surreal views of dramatic cliffs and the North Atlantic.
Top 3 Attractions: Football on the Emerald Isle with Belfast
Enjoy two of your interests – travel and football – on one incredible adventure! This exciting trip focuses heavily on exploring the country of Ireland, but begins in Northern Ireland, where Belfast and Giant’s Causeway welcome us. Visiting both of these amazing countries and experiencing the thrill of college football across the pond, cultural splendor, and breathtaking natural beauty, make this a getaway unlike any other.
The most prominent highlight of this tour is, of course, enjoying the Aer Lingus College Football Classic at Aviva Stadium! Cheer on your team in the Touchdown Club’s shared hospitality suite with early admission, an open bar, a commemorative lanyard, all-day gourmet grazing menus, and a VIP guest wallet and invitation. If that wasn’t enough, you’ll also enjoy comfortable, padded seating in a covered area connected to the suite for optimal viewing of the heart-pumping game!
Feel the echoes of ancient chants and marvel at medieval craftsmanship while visiting the Clonmacnoise monastic site. Positioned along the banks of River Shannon, this once-thriving center of religion, learning, and trade was a hub for scholars and pilgrims. The ruins tell the story of the monastery’s vast impact on Europe from the 6th century through the late 12th century. See the original high crosses, ruins of seven churches, round towers, and some early Christian grave slabs.
Watch the history of Irish emigration come to life at Ulster American Folk Park, an open-air museum that details the journey of countless Irish men and women who left their homeland for a new life in America. Wander through recreated thatched cottages, village streets, and working farms, then cross the "Atlantic" to explore authentic American frontier cabins. Along the way, get a glimpse at their daily lives with demonstrations of traditional crafts, cooking, and blacksmithing.
Top 3 Attractions: Scotland’s Glens & Highlands
If you’re interested in an adventure that focuses Scotland’s scenic grandeur, mystic lochs, and rich history – this is for you! From the rugged Highlands to the enchanting castles that dot the countryside, this country feels like stepping into a storybook. With its warm hospitality, lively traditions, and world-famous whisky, this is a destination that offers something for everyone.
Uncover countless stories that shaped Scotland at one of the country’s grandest castles, Stirling Castle. As the childhood home of Mary Queen of Scots, the tumultuous events that occurred while she lived in the fortress helped shape her reign. See the spot where she was crowned in 1543, admire the opulent Great Hall, stand in the chapel where Charles I’s coronation was held, hear about great battles like Bannockburn, and more. Outside, take in breathtaking views of the lush Stirling countryside and the distant Highlands.
Board a beautiful catamaran for a cruise along the famous Caledonian Canal, a 19th-century engineering marvel that takes us into the legendary Loch Ness. These waters have many stories to tell – such as the crash of a World War II Wellington Bomber, visits from Queen Victoria and other royals, a world-famous monster hunter who lives nearby, and the mythical monster who inhabits the depths. Take in views of the Scottish Highlands, Great Glen, Bona Lighthouse, and the imposing ruins of Urquhart Castle!
Explore St. Andrews, renowned as the birthplace of golf and home to one of the oldest golf clubs in the world: The Royal and Ancient Golf Club. Visit its Pro Shop and see other iconic attractions, such as the University of St. Andrews, St. Andrews Castle, and the ruins of St. Andrews Cathedral, once the largest church in Scotland. This picturesque town is also a haven for literary enthusiasts. You may find inspiration in the charming streets and cozy cafes, much like J.K. Rowling did.
Top 3 Attractions: Scottish Charm & Irish Farms
This unique tour visits all three countries, with an emphasis on the beautiful scenery and agricultural wonders of each. Meet local farmers in the gorgeous countryside, sample fresh farm-to-table foods, and dive into what makes the cuisine in these regions so incredible! We also spend plenty of time exploring the most iconic attractions, from Scotland’s castles to Ireland’s lively cities.
Cruise through Loch Lomond, a freshwater loch surrounded by the majestic peaks of Trossachs National Park. It spans the geological fault line, which naturally splits Scotland’s sprawling Lowlands and craggy Highland mountains. Watch for wildlife and enjoy spectacular views of Arklet Falls, Arrochar Alps, and more while listening to various tales of the Highlands, steeped in clans with deep loyalties. By surface area, Loch Lomond is also the largest freshwater lake in Britain!
Visit the National Museum of Rural Life, a five-star museum and working commercial dairy farm, to see how Scotland’s country life has evolved throughout the years. Learn how the same area of land can produce three times more food than a century ago, see a beautifully preserved 1950s Georgian farmhouse, and browse an expansive collection of equipment, including tractors, harvesters, and combines. The Study Store alone houses over 6,000 historic objects, like peat spades and blacksmithing tools!
Walk in the footsteps of royalty and soldiers as you visit Edinburgh Castle, previously an important military stronghold, royal residence, military garrison, and prison. The castle stands proudly on Castle Rock and is home to Mons Meg, one of the greatest medieval cannons ever made. Stroll the Half Moon Battery, built in the aftermath of the Lang Siege of 1573 and armed with bronze guns known as the Seven Sisters. In the Crown Room, admire the ancient Honours of Scotland including the crown, scepter, and Sword of State.
Now that you have a better understanding of these awe-inspiring regions and a glimpse of what to expect on each trip, we hope you feel clarity on which is perfect for your next getaway. There is no right or wrong answer – in fact, we believe all three countries belong on your bucket list because they are all uniquely their own. No matter your choice, we will be here to provide worry-free travel filled with enrichment and excitement.
When you’re ready to book the trip of a lifetime, simply click on the tour you’re interested in, select your desired departure date, and securely reserve your spot online in minutes with a low $200 deposit – fully refundable until the final payment date. If you have questions or would like additional guidance in choosing the right trip for you, our expert Tour Sales Consultants are happy to help. You can reach them between 8 AM and 5 PM (CT), Monday through Friday, at 1-888-867-2190. We look forward to taking you on a memorable adventure across the pond!